My Husband Got My Best Friend Pregnant Until I Planned A Surprise At The Gender Reveal

“I don’t want to turn my baby’s celebration into a disaster,” I said.

“Then you don’t have to,” Lauren said. “We can cancel. I can tell everybody the venue flooded. You don’t have to do any of this.”

“But Paige is planning an announcement,” I said. “And Ryan knows about it. Or knows she wants to. If I cancel, she’ll just find another time. Another place. Thanksgiving. Christmas. The hospital. She’ll find a way to tell everybody. On her terms.”

Lauren sighed.

“So what would you like me to do?”

I thought about it carefully.

For a long time.

“Keep the original photographs,” I said. “The wedding. The house. Paige and me as teenagers. All of it. Exactly like it is.”

“Okay.”

“And then show four messages.”

“Which ones?”

“The ones that tell the truth,” I said.

I sent her the screenshots.

Four of them. I chose them very carefully.

I didn’t send the photographs. I didn’t send the hotel reservations. I didn’t send February 19th. That one was mine. That one I wasn’t going to share with anybody.

The first one confirmed that Ryan was the father of Paige’s baby. How are we going to explain to Natalie why both babies will look like you?

The second one showed Paige expecting them to become a family. Can’t wait until everyone knows we’re a family.

The third one was Ryan’s reply. I told you Saturday isn’t the time.

And the last one was the argument. You said you’d leave Natalie. And underneath it: I can’t do that while she’s pregnant. Think about how it would look.

Lauren studied them for a long time on her end. I could hear her breathing.

“Do you want the messages shown before the cake?” she asked.

“Yes.”

“Are you still planning to reveal the gender?”

I hesitated.

I’d waited for that moment for three years. Thirty-one negative tests. I’d dreamed about cutting into that cake and seeing pink or blue spill out. I’d dreamed about Ryan kissing me. Everybody cheering.

I shook my head. Even though Lauren couldn’t see me.

“Not there,” I said. “Not in front of them.”

“Okay.”

“I don’t want the moment I waited three years for buried under their betrayal,” I said. “That moment’s mine. Not theirs.”

“I’ll keep the envelope sealed,” Lauren said. “I’ll give it to you after. Whenever you’re ready.”

Saturday arrived.

I woke up at six. I didn’t need an alarm. I hadn’t really slept.

I put on a pale green maternity dress. Soft and loose, with a little bow at the back. I’d bought it a month earlier, specially for the party. Green because it was neither pink nor blue.

I did my hair. I put on makeup. I looked at myself in the bathroom mirror for a long time.

My hands were shaking.

I made them stop.

Ryan came up behind me in the mirror. He was wearing a gray suit. A pink-and-blue striped tie that Paige had picked out for him.

He kissed my forehead.

“You look beautiful,” he said.

“Thank you.”

He put his hand on my stomach.

“Ready for the big surprise?” he said.

I looked at him in the mirror.

“Absolutely,” I said.

At the event room, our families were already gathering.

Pink and blue balloons everywhere. The HE OR SHE? banner across the front wall. The three-tier white cake on a table at the front, under the big screen. Little cupcakes with question marks.

My mother hugged me at the door. She’s sixty-two. A retired school nurse. Small and fierce, with short gray hair and reading glasses on a chain.

She held me at arm’s length and looked at my face.

“You seem nervous, honey.”

“I am.”

“Everything’s going to be fine.”

I squeezed her hand.

“Mama,” I said. “Whatever happens today. Will you stay close to me?”

She looked at me for a long moment. Something changed in her eyes.

“Natalie,” she said. “What’s going on?”

“Just stay close. Okay?”

She didn’t ask anything else. She just nodded.

“I’m not going anywhere,” she said.

Across the room, Paige was arranging the cupcakes on a tiered stand.

She was wearing the blue dress. My dress. The one I’d bought her.

When she saw me, she put down the cupcakes and hurried over.

“Nat! You look gorgeous!”

She threw her arms around me.

I stood very still.

“Thanks,” I said.

She pulled back. She was beaming. Her eyes were bright.

“Today’s going to be unforgettable,” she said.

I looked at her.

“Yes,” I said. “It is.”

Ryan came over.

For a moment, the three of us stood there together. In the middle of the room. Surrounded by pink and blue balloons.

My husband. My best friend. And me.

They exchanged a glance. Just for a second. Over my head.

I saw it.

And I wondered how many times they’d done that. In my kitchen. At my birthday parties. At my wedding. While I was standing right there between them.

The party started normally.

People ate. They laughed. They took pictures with the balloons. Ryan’s father, Dale, told the same story about Ryan falling out of a tree house when he was eight that he tells at every single family gathering. Ryan’s mother, Joyce, cried twice before anything even happened.

The slideshow started playing on the big screen.

Pictures from our wedding. My mother’s backyard. Ryan dipping me on the dance floor.

Pictures from our honeymoon in Savannah.

Pictures of our little brick house with the maple tree. The day we got the keys.

Then pictures of Paige and me. As teenagers. Prom. Spring break in Florida. The crappy apartment near Ohio State.

Everybody smiled. Somebody said aww.

I watched Paige. She was standing by the cake table. Studying the screen. Her hand on her stomach.

I watched Ryan. He was standing by the windows. Checking his phone.

Finally, Lauren walked to the front of the room. She clapped her hands.

“Okay, everybody! It’s time! Time for the cake!”

Everybody cheered. They started gathering around the cake table. My mother. Ryan’s parents. My aunts. His cousins. Our friends from work.

Ryan came and stood next to me. On my right.

Paige moved closer. On my left. Right next to me. Just like Ryan wanted.

Lauren handed me the cake knife. A big silver one, with a pink and blue ribbon tied around the handle.

Then she handed me the microphone.

I held the cake knife in one hand. The microphone in the other.

I didn’t cut the cake.

I lifted the microphone.

“Dear guests,” I said. My voice was steady. I don’t know how. “Before we cut the cake, I have one more special surprise. For two very important people in my life.”

Ryan smiled. Uncertainly.

Paige’s face lit up.

She thought this was it. I could see it in her eyes. She thought I knew something. She thought maybe I was going to announce something about the two of us. Best friends. Becoming mothers together.

I looked at them both.

“These two people,” I said, “have been part of my happiest memories.”

I nodded toward Lauren.

The screen changed.

A photograph came up.

Paige and me. At my wedding. She was in her lavender bridesmaid’s dress. I was in my white gown. We had our arms around each other. We were laughing so hard our eyes were closed.

Underneath it, in white letters:

Twenty years of friendship. Five years of marriage.

Everybody murmured. Aww. That’s so sweet. Ryan’s mother put her hand over her heart.

Paige put her hand over her mouth. Her eyes filled with tears.

Then the photograph disappeared.

And a text message appeared in its place.

A gray bubble. Huge. Filling the whole screen.

How are we going to explain to Natalie why both babies will look like you?

The room went silent.

Completely silent. Fifty people, and not one of them made a sound.

Ryan’s smile vanished.

Paige went white. Paper white.

Another message came up.

Can’t wait until everyone knows we’re a family.

Then Ryan’s reply. With his name over it. Ryan.

I told you Saturday isn’t the time.

And then, finally, the argument.

Paige: You said you’d leave Natalie.

Ryan: I can’t do that while she’s pregnant. Think about how it would look.

Somebody gasped.

I think it was Ryan’s aunt Carol.

My mother covered her mouth with both hands.

Ryan’s mother, Joyce, made a sound like she’d been hit in the stomach.

Ryan lunged for the microphone in my hand.

“Natalie,” he said. “Stop.”

I stepped back. Out of his reach.

“No,” I said.

Paige was shaking her head. Back and forth. Back and forth.

“Nat,” she said. “Nat, please. Please.”

I turned and looked at her.

“Is this the announcement you wanted Lauren to make?” I said. Into the microphone. So everybody could hear. “After the cake? With the screen on? Is this it, Paige? Is this what was on your flash drive?”

Her face drained of what little color it had left.

Ryan turned toward Paige.

His face was red. Furious.

“You contacted the planner?” he said. “You actually went to the planner? I told you…”

“You promised!” Paige cried. Her voice cracked. “You promised me, Ryan! You said after the babies! You said you’d tell her!”

The guests started whispering. A low rumble, all around the room.

Ryan lowered his voice.

“Not here,” he hissed at her. “Paige. Not here.”

I almost laughed.

Even now. Even with the whole thing up on a giant screen in front of his mother and his father and his grandmother.

He was still trying to decide when the truth could be spoken.

Not here. Not Saturday. Not while she’s pregnant. After the baby. Not yet. Not now.

I turned to face our families.

All of them. Standing there frozen around the cake table. Holding their paper plates and their glasses of punch.

“Ryan,” I said into the microphone, “is the father of Paige’s baby.”

Nobody moved.

“And apparently,” I said, “he’s been promising both of us a future.”

I looked down at the cake. The three-tier white cake with the pink and blue ribbon. Untouched.

“I thought today was going to be about finding out something wonderful,” I said.

My voice trembled. Just a little.

“Instead,” I said, “I found out what they’ve been hiding.”

Ryan stepped toward me.

“Natalie. Please. I can explain.”

“Did you tell Paige you’d leave me?”

He hesitated.

“Things got complicated.”

“Yes or no, Ryan.”

He looked at his mother. He looked at his father. He looked at the floor.

“Yes,” he said.

Paige started crying. Loud, heaving sobs.

“He told me he loved me,” she said. To me. To the room. To anybody. “He told me he loved me, Nat. He said your marriage was over. He said he was just waiting for the right time.”

I turned toward her.

“And you told me,” I said, “that your baby’s father disappeared.”

She looked down at the floor.

“I didn’t know how to tell you,” she whispered.

“You had months, Paige.”

“I was scared. I was scared of losing you.”

I stared at her.

“You let me buy things for your baby,” I said.

She looked up at me. Tears all down her face. Her mascara running, just like mine in the second-floor bathroom twenty years ago.

“I never asked you to,” she said.

That answer hurt more than anything else that day.

More than the messages on the screen. More than Ryan’s yes.

I never asked you to.

“No,” I said quietly. “You didn’t. You just let me believe you were alone.”

Ryan reached for my arm.

I stepped back.

“Don’t,” I said.

He looked around the room. At all the faces. His mother crying. His father staring at the floor. My mother standing very straight, with her chin up, watching him like a hawk.

“Can we please,” Ryan said, “discuss this privately?”

“We can discuss what happens next,” I said. “But not today.”

I put the microphone down on the table next to the cake. Next to the silver knife with the pink and blue ribbon.

I looked at Lauren.

“You can turn off the screen now,” I said.

She nodded. She pressed a button on her laptop.

The screen went black.

My mother came to my side. She took my arm.

“Come home with me,” she said.

I nodded.

We walked toward the door. Through the crowd. People stepped back to let us through. Nobody said anything. Ryan’s grandmother, who’s ninety-one, reached out and squeezed my hand as I passed.

Ryan followed us.

“Natalie,” he said. “Natalie, please. Please. Think about our baby.”

I stopped at the door.

I turned around.

“I have been,” I said. “That’s all I’ve been thinking about.”

“I love you,” Ryan said.

I looked at him.

At his gray suit. At his pink-and-blue tie that Paige picked out. At the face I’d woken up next to every morning for five years.

“Then you should have acted like it,” I said.

He had no answer.

Behind him, Paige was still standing next to the cake.

In my blue dress. Alone. With her hands over her face.

I looked at her for a long moment.

I remembered two teenage girls sitting on the floor of the second-floor bathroom at Westlake High, laughing so hard they couldn’t breathe. Promising each other they’d be sisters forever. No matter what.

Then I turned around.

And I walked away.

I stayed with my mother that night.

In my old bedroom. In the little house in Grandview where I grew up. With the same pink wallpaper I picked out when I was nine.

My mother made me grilled cheese and tomato soup. The same thing she made me when I was sick as a kid.

She sat on the edge of my bed while I ate it.

“How long have you known?” she asked quietly.

“Since Wednesday.”

“Three days,” she said. “And you went to that party anyway. You did all that by yourself.”

“I had to know what they were planning.”

My mother was quiet for a long time.

“Your father,” she said finally, “would have been so proud of you. And so angry. He’d have flattened that boy.”

I laughed. It turned into crying.

My mother took the soup bowl out of my hands and pulled me into her arms. And I cried like I hadn’t cried since I was a little girl.

Ryan called me forty-one times that night.

I didn’t answer.

Paige sent me a long text message. Three screens long. I read it once.

Nat, I’m so sorry. I’m so so sorry. I never meant for any of this to happen. It started as one night. One stupid night. After a party. And then it just kept happening. I hated myself the whole time. I hated lying to you. I swear I did. Every time you bought me something, I wanted to die. I wanted to tell you so many times. I’m so sorry about February. I’m so sorry about everything. I don’t expect you to forgive me. I just need you to know I love you. I’ve always loved you. You’re my sister.

I didn’t answer that either.

The next morning, I sent Ryan one message.

I need space. We’ll discuss arrangements for the baby when I’m ready. Please don’t come to my mother’s house.

Then I silenced my phone and put it in a drawer.

The week after that was hard.

I’m not going to pretend it wasn’t.

I didn’t go back to our house. My mother and my cousin Jess went and got my things. My clothes. My books. The pregnancy book with all the dog-eared pages. The little stuffed elephant I’d bought for the nursery.

Ryan wasn’t there when they went. He’d moved into a hotel. I don’t know which one. I didn’t ask.

I called a lawyer. A woman named Patricia Reyes, who’d handled my cousin’s divorce. She was calm and sharp and didn’t flinch when I showed her the screenshots.

“Okay,” she said. “First things first. You’re not going to make any big decisions until after this baby is born. Unless you want to. You understand? You’ve got time.”

“Okay.”

“Second. You protect yourself. Your money. Your name. Everything. Starting today.”

“Okay.”

“And third,” Patricia said. She took off her glasses. “You take care of that baby. That’s your only job right now. Let me do the rest.”

Ryan’s mother called me on Thursday.

I almost didn’t answer. But I did.

“Natalie,” Joyce said. Her voice was shaking. “I’m so sorry, honey. I’m so, so sorry. I didn’t know. None of us knew. Dale is… Dale hasn’t spoken to him since Saturday. He won’t even say his name.”

“I know you didn’t know, Joyce.”

“I raised him better than this. I swear I did.”

“I know.”

She was quiet for a long time.

“I just want you to know,” Joyce said finally, “that whatever happens with you and Ryan. That baby is my grandchild. And you’re my daughter. You’ve been my daughter for five years. Nothing that boy did changes that.”

I sat on the edge of my childhood bed and cried for the third time that day.

A week after the party, on a Saturday morning, Lauren came to my mother’s house.

She was holding a small white envelope.

The envelope from my doctor. Sealed. With BROOKS — CONFIDENTIAL written on the front in black marker.

“I promised I’d bring this whenever you were ready,” Lauren said, standing on the porch. “I wasn’t sure if you’d ever be ready. But your mom called me yesterday. She said you were asking about it.”

I took the envelope.

“Thank you, Lauren,” I said. “For everything. For not adding that announcement. For all of it.”

“Natalie,” Lauren said. “I’ve done four hundred and twelve events in my career. Weddings. Birthdays. Retirements. Funerals. I’ve never seen anybody stand up the way you did on Saturday.” She shook her head. “I’m sorry the cake never got cut.”

“It’s okay,” I said. “I’ll find out a different way.”

My mother and I sat down together at her kitchen table. The same table where she taught me to make pie crust when I was eight. The same table where she told me my father had died.

I held the envelope in both hands.

It had never been cut. The cake. It had sat there on that table at Lucia’s with its pink and blue ribbon, untouched, while everybody filed out of the room in silence. Lauren had taken it home and given it to a homeless shelter on High Street. Somebody there got to find out the color of my baby. I hoped they enjoyed it.

“Do you want me to open it?” my mother asked.

“No,” I said. “I want to.”

I slid my finger under the flap. I pulled out a little folded card. White. From the doctor’s office.

I unfolded it.

“It’s a girl,” I whispered.

My mother let out a breath.

She was smiling. Tears running down her face.

“A little girl,” she said.

“A little girl,” I said.

I put my hand on my stomach. The baby kicked. Hard. Right against my palm. Like she’d heard.

I’d imagined that moment for three years.

I’d imagined it with Ryan. Cutting into a cake. Pink spilling out. Him lifting me off the ground and spinning me around while everybody cheered.

Instead, I was sitting at my mother’s kitchen table in Grandview on a Saturday morning, in my old pajamas, with a cup of ginger tea going cold.

Sharing it with the one person in my whole life who had never once made me question her loyalty.

It wasn’t what I’d imagined.

It was better.

I named her Eleanor. After my father’s mother. Ellie.

She was born on a Tuesday in early November. Seven pounds, eleven ounces. A full head of dark hair and the loudest scream on the whole labor and delivery floor.

My mother was in the room. She held my hand for nineteen hours. Joyce was in the waiting room. She’d driven up from Dayton and refused to leave.

Ryan was there too.

I’d told him he could come to the hospital. Not to the delivery room. To the waiting room. Patricia said it was my choice. I chose to let him see his daughter.

When the nurse brought him in, after, he stood in the doorway for a long time. He didn’t come in. He just stood there.

“Can I hold her?” he asked.

I looked at him.

“You can hold her,” I said.

He held her for twenty minutes. He cried the whole time. He didn’t say anything. He just looked at her.

When he handed her back, he said, “Thank you, Nat.”

“You’re welcome.”

“I’m so sorry.”

“I know,” I said.

Paige had her baby three weeks later.

A boy. I heard about it from Joyce. She called me the day he was born.

“His name is Owen,” Joyce said quietly. “Ryan was there. He’s… Natalie, I don’t know what to say. He’s my grandson too. I don’t know how to feel about any of it.”

“You’re allowed to love him, Joyce,” I said. “He didn’t do anything wrong. He’s a baby.”

She was quiet on the other end.

“You really mean that?”

“I mean it.”

Ryan and I divorced the following spring.

It wasn’t loud. It wasn’t ugly. He didn’t fight me on anything. He signed every page Patricia put in front of him. He pays his child support on the first of the month, every month.

He sees Ellie every other weekend. And Wednesday evenings. At first, supervised, at my mother’s house. Then, after a while, not.

He’s a decent father. I’ll give him that. He’s patient. He reads to her. He does the voices.

He and Paige didn’t last.

They tried for about four months after Owen was born. They lived together in an apartment in Dublin. Then Paige found messages on his phone. From a woman at his office.

I didn’t say anything when I heard. I didn’t have to.

Paige wrote me a letter last fall.

A real letter. Handwritten. On paper. Mailed to my new apartment.

I almost threw it away without opening it.

I didn’t.

Nat,

I’m not writing to ask you for anything. I know I don’t have the right.

I just want you to know I think about February 19th every single day. I think about sitting on your couch holding your hand and telling you you’d be a mother someday. And then going home and texting him. I think about it when I’m feeding Owen at three in the morning. I think about it when I’m driving. I think about it in the shower.

I don’t know who that person was. I don’t know how I let myself become her.

I’m in therapy now. Twice a week. My therapist asked me what I lost. I said I lost Ryan. She said no, try again. I said I lost my dignity. She said try again.

I said I lost my sister.

She said, that’s the one.

I’m so sorry, Natalie. For all of it. Especially for “I never asked you to.” That was the worst thing I’ve ever said to anybody. You didn’t have to be asked. You never had to be asked. That’s who you are. That’s who you always were.

Ellie is lucky to have you. Owen would be too.

— P.

I didn’t write back.

I’m not ready. I don’t know if I ever will be.

But I kept the letter. It’s in a box in my closet. Next to the blue maternity dress, which she mailed back to me with it, dry-cleaned and folded in tissue paper.

I don’t know why she sent it back. Maybe she couldn’t stand to look at it anymore.

I don’t know what I’m going to do with it either. Maybe someday I’ll give it to a friend who needs it. Somebody who’s pregnant and alone and scared.

Somebody who’s actually telling me the truth.

Ellie is a year old now.

She has dark hair and big brown eyes and a laugh that sounds like hiccups. She can walk, sort of, if you hold her hands. She says Mama and Gamma and dog and no. Mostly no.

Last month, Ryan brought Owen with him on his Saturday with Ellie. He asked me first. He called three days ahead and asked.

“I’d like them to know each other,” he said. “Someday. If that’s okay with you. They’re brother and sister, Nat. Whatever I did. That’s not their fault.”

I thought about it for a long time.

“Okay,” I said.

They sat on the floor of my mother’s living room together. Ellie and Owen. Eleven months and ten months old. Ellie handed Owen a wooden block. Owen put it in his mouth. Ellie laughed her hiccup laugh.

I sat on the couch with my mother and watched them.

They don’t know anything yet. They don’t know about the tablet or the screen or the cake that never got cut.

They just know there’s another baby on the floor who’s fun to play with.

Maybe that’s enough. For now.

People ask me sometimes if I regret it. The slideshow. Putting it all up on the screen in front of everybody.

I tell them the truth.

I regret that I had to. I regret that it came to that. I regret that the day I dreamed about for three years became the day everybody remembers for something else.

But I don’t regret telling the truth.

They were going to tell it anyway. Paige had a flash drive in her purse. Ryan had a plan to keep both of us waiting forever. The truth was going to come out at my party one way or another.

I just made sure it came out in my words. On my terms. Before they could decide how I learned it.

Ellie’s first birthday was last week.

We had a party in my mother’s backyard. Twenty people. Joyce and Dale. My aunts. My cousin Jess. Lauren, who’s become a friend. Patricia Reyes, my lawyer, who brought a stuffed giraffe the size of a small car.

Ryan came for an hour. He brought Owen. He stood at the edge of the yard and didn’t say much. He gave Ellie a little wooden rocking horse he’d built himself. It took him three months, he said.

There was a cake.

A small one. White frosting. Pink inside. My mother made it herself.

When it was time, I stood behind Ellie’s high chair with the knife.

I cut the cake.

Ellie screamed with joy and put both hands straight into the frosting.

Everybody cheered.

I don’t know what my daughter’s future is going to look like. Nobody does.

But I know what I want her to understand when she’s old enough. When she asks about her dad. When she asks about Owen. When she asks about the woman in the old photographs, laughing with me in a lavender dress.

I want her to know this.

Being loved should never mean accepting being lied to.

And becoming a family takes a lot more than making promises.

It takes keeping them.

Categories:

Stories

Previous page 1 2

Related Articles

Back to top button