Simon Cowells Last Minute Britains Got Talent Shock The Judge Who Almost Joined the Show and the Woman Who Took Her Place

Cowell wanted a panel that could provide that variety.

According to accounts of the story he later shared, Cheryl Cole was originally offered the opportunity to join Britain’s Got Talent as a judge. At the time, she was already a prominent name in British pop culture, known for her work with Girls Aloud and her growing television profile. Her presence could have given the new programme an immediate connection to the music and entertainment world.

The plan, however, did not survive until filming.

In a 2016 report, ITV News described Cowell as confirming that Cheryl had been expected to take the place eventually occupied by Amanda Holden. Cowell said that Cheryl had been due to join the programme but backed out with only days remaining before filming. The account was later revisited in 2025, when Cowell discussed the near-miss again while reflecting on the programme’s long history.

The details make the story compelling because the change happened at such a sensitive moment. A production can spend months planning a new show, but a last-minute change to its central personalities can force the team to rethink the entire balance.

The judging panel was not a minor detail. It was one of the main attractions.

Why Cheryl Cole Was Considered for the Role

Cheryl Cole was a major entertainment figure when the original Britain’s Got Talent panel was being put together. Her popularity had grown through Girls Aloud, the group formed on the television talent competition Popstars: The Rivals. The group became one of the most successful British girl groups of its era, building a large audience through hit records, performances, and a recognizable public image.